Erie County Common Pleas Court Links

Erie County Common Pleas Court Links provided by Sly Bail Bonds of Ashland

Erie County courthouse - bail bondsmanSEARCH COURT DOCKET

Local Court Rules

Local Court Forms

Erie County Most Wanted



323 Columbus Avenue, Second Floor
Sandusky, OH 44870
Phone: (419) 627-7731
Fax: (419) 627-6602

Judge Roger E. Binette

Steven C. Bechtel
Christopher A. Stallkamp

Phone: (419) 627-7732
Fax: (419) 627-6692

Vicki Fitzgerald,
Court Administrator

Lori Rickenbaugh,
Judicial Administrator/
Offical Court Reporter


Judge Tygh M. Tone

Magistrate Patrick J. Quinn
Phone: (419) 627-6691
Email: [email protected]

Beth Naufel, Court Administrator & Civil Assignment Commissioner
Phone: (419) 627-6674
Email: [email protected]

Christine Reggi, Official Court Reporter & Criminal Assignment Commissioner
Phone: (419) 624-6920
Email: [email protected]

Susan Kelsey, Law Clerk
Phone: (419) 627-6675
Email: [email protected]

Lee Jacobs, Domestic Relations Assignment Commissioner & Mental Health Court Coordinator
Phone: (419) 627-7585
Email: [email protected]

Lisa Sartor, Jury Commissioner & Assistant Criminal & Domestic Relations Clerk
Phone: (419) 624-6915
Email: [email protected]

Sheryl Finken, Civil Clerk & Support Staff
Phone: (419) 627-7589
Email: [email protected]

Hours of Operation:

Monday – Friday
8:00 a.m. – 4:00 p.m.

Criminal Division

The Criminal Division of Erie County Clerk of Courts is responsible for overseeing and retaining records in felony cases.  The Criminal Division also maintains and administers filed documents in escape cases, extraditions from other states and expungements.  Crimes are considered offenses against the State of Ohio.  Thus, if a person commits a crime against another, it is considered an offense to everyone in society.  Therefore, criminal cases are prosecuted by the State of Ohio, and the prosecutor (not the victim) files the case in court as a representative of the State.


Appeal to the Sixth District Court of Appeals $150.00 
Motion to Expunge Record per case, nonrefundable $100.00
Certificate of Qualification for Employment $100.00
Effective 8/1/2013
All criminal copies obtained from the Clerk’s Office $0.25
All criminal certified copies obtained from the Clerk’s Office $2.00
Exception: No fee required for Certified Copies needed for entrance into school.However, proper documentation must accompany the request.
Precipe for Subpena – In State Case (PDF, 22KB)

Understanding The Felony System – Definitions For Victims

As the criminal case in which you were victimized progresses through the judicial system, you will receive notices from this office advising you of different types of hearings. Those are explained as follows:


The defendant is brought before the judge to enter a plea of guilty or not guilty. If he/she cannot afford an attorney to present him/her, the Court will appoint one. The matter of bond, which insures a defendant’s appearance at all hearings, will be decided by the Court.


In Erie County, only the lawyers and the Judge/Magistrate are present for the pretrial, which is held in the Judge’s chambers. Both parties advise the Court of the basic facts in the case. The Court may also inquire to any legal issues that need to be resolved prior to trial, such as a motion to suppress any evidence intended to be offered by the Prosecuting Attorney. The Court will also discuss the length of any proposed trial and if there are any possibilities for a plea. The defense attorney will also inquire as to the possible sentence if a plea should occur. Many cases are resolved at a pretrial stage via plea negotiations, however, any discussions of possible plea or sentencing would be discussed with the victim prior to acceptance of same. Although the goals of victims are not always attainable, we want and need your input.


This proceeding is where evidence pertaining to the case is presented to either a jury or to the Judge. Victims and witnesses are generally excluded from the trial due to a motion for “separation of witnesses.” This is to prevent a witness from hearing what another witness has testified to and then changing his/her testimony. However, if any family members, relatives, or friends wish to attend the trial, they certainly have the right to do so. A trial is a hectic time for a Prosecuting Attorney, and he/she will likely have little time to confer with you during the trial. A Victim/Witness Advocate will keep you informed as to the status of the trial.


A plea indicates that the defendant is going to plead guilty to some charges. He/She may plead guilty as charged, or to some lesser charges. you have the right to be present at any plea. Unless there is a mandatory sentence, a defendant is generally referred to the Adult Probation Department for a presentence investigation. Therefore, attendance at a plea by a victim is generally nonproductive. The most productive time for a victim is in answering the questions of the probation officer during the presentence period. You will be sent a form to complete – VICTIMS IMPACT STATEMENT (PDF, 703KB). – which is your opportunity to tell the court what has occurred, any damages you have suffered, how you have been affected by the crime, as well as your opinion as to what should happen to the defendant. Although you have the right to be present at sentencing, and may be allowed to address the Court, in most cases the Judge has already made a decision. Therefore, it is important that you complete the Victims Impact Statement (PDF, 703KB). and return it to the Adult Probation Department prior to the sentencing hearing, so they can make an accurate recommendation to the court.


Except in the case of mandatory sentences, sentencing is up to the Court within general guidelines. Sentencing occurs in open court and you have the right to be present. The Court generally asks the prosecution if it has anything to say concerning sentencing. At that time, the Prosecuting Attorney also notifies the Court whether or not the victim is present, and, if present, if the victim would like to address the Court. Any written statements are made available to the defense attorney. Thereafter, the defense attorney and the defendant are given an opportunity to say anything in mitigation of the sentence. The Court then issues its decision as to the sentence to be served by the defendant.

We hope that this will help you understand the notices received during the judicial process and the terminology involved.

The Office of the Erie County Prosecuting Attorney is located on the 3rd floor of the Erie County Office Building, 247 Columbus Avenue, Suite 319, Sandusky, Ohio 44870. The Office can be contacted through the following:

MAIN OFFICE 419-627-7697
Criminal Division 419-627-7698
Civil Division/Foreclosures 419-627-7687
Juvenile Division 419-627-7697
Grand Jury 419-627-7540
Victim/Witness Division 419-627-7699
Facsimile 419-627-7567


Kevin J. Baxter          Erie County Prosecutor
Mary Ann Barylski     Chief Assistant
Vicki R. Palmer         Assistant Prosecutor
Jeanne M. Lippert    Assistant Prosecutor
Ashley Thomas         Assistant Prosecutor
Susan R. Brown       Assistant Prosecutor
Nicholas J. Smith     Assistant Prosecutor
Cheryl Goodrum      Assistant Prosecutor
Frank Zeleznikar     Assistant Prosecutor


Office Manager Brenda L. Oeder 419-627-7540
Secretary Connie Toomey 419-627-7698
Secretary Jean Hilvers 419-627-7687
Secretary Margaret Gallagher 419-627-6919
Secretary Shelley Jarrett 419-499-8129
Investigator Paul Schnittker 419-627-7695